59-1504. Whenever a decedent by will makes a provision for the compensation of his or her executor, that shall be taken as such executor's full compensation, unless the executor files a written instrument, renouncing all claim to the compensation provided for in the will. Whenever any person named in a will or codicil defends it, or prosecutes any proceedings in good faith and with just cause, for the purpose of having it admitted to probate, whether successful or not, or if any person successfully opposes the probate of any will or codicil, such person shall be allowed out of the estate his or her necessary expenses and disbursements in such proceedings, together with such compensation for such person's services and those of his or her attorneys as shall be just and proper.
Any heir at law or beneficiary under a will who, in good faith and for good cause, successfully prosecutes or defends any other action for the benefit of the ultimate recipients of the estate may be allowed his or her necessary expenses, in the discretion of the court, including a reasonable attorney's fee.
History: L. 1939, ch. 180, § 115; L. 1941, ch. 284, § 16; L. 1975, ch. 299, § 11; January 1, 1976.
Source or prior law:
22-317, 22-919, 22-920, 38-227, 62-2024.
Cross References to Related Sections:
Compensation and expenses of fiduciary and attorneys, see 59-1717.
Law Review and Bar Journal References:
1963-65 survey of damages, David Prager, 14 K.L.R. 241, 248 (1965).
"A Practical Review of the 1975 Kansas Probate Code Revisions," Philip S. Frick, 44 J.B.A.K. 137, 182 (1975).
"Recovery of Attorney Fees in Kansas," Mark A. Furney, 18 W.L.J. 535, 561 (1979).
"Survey of Kansas Law: Wills, Trusts, and Probate," 29 K.L.R. 595, 602 (1981).
"Will Substitutes in Kansas," Jana J. Deines and Michael E. McMahon, 23 W.L.J. 132 (1983).
"Attorney Fees: The Meaning of 'Successfully Opposes the Probate of a Will' For a Grant of Attorney Fees Under Kan. Stat. Ann. § 59-1504," Lillian Apodaca, 23 W.L.J. 399, 404, 405, 406, 407, 408 (1984).
"Will Contests in Kansas," Dennis M. Feeney & Jeffery L. Carmichael, 64 J.K.B.A. No. 7, 22, 23 (1995).
CASE ANNOTATIONS
1. Lack of good faith in prosecuting probate of will; costs taxed against proponents. In re Estate of Casida, 156 Kan. 73, 78, 131 P.2d 644.
2. Attorney's fees incurred in prosecuting suit for specific performance of contract disallowed. In re Estate of Davis, 171 Kan. 605, 606, 613, 237 P.2d 396.
3. Action to include property in inventory successful; attorney fee properly allowed. In re Estate of Rooney, 186 Kan. 200, 203, 349 P.2d 916.
4. Facts considered and allowance of partial attorneys' and executors' fees upheld. In re Estate of Snyder, 188 Kan. 46, 49, 360 P.2d 883.
5. District court has authority to allow attorney fees in defense of a will. In re Estate of Roberts, 192 Kan. 91, 92, 101, 102, 386 P.2d 301.
6. Where meritorious action brought to construe will, attorney fees allowed hereunder. Baldwin v. Hambleton, 196 Kan. 353, 361, 411 P.2d 626.
7. Issues involving attorney fees determined in In re Estate of Roberts, 192 Kan. 91, held res judicata, Coffey, Administrator v. Gilbert, 204 Kan. 305, 307, 461 P.2d 747.
8. District court authorized to make allowance for attorney's fee under the statute. In re Estate of Showers, 207 Kan. 268, 275, 485 P.2d 299.
9. Cited; attorney fees incurred by beneficiaries to determine validity of antenuptial contract generally not chargeable against estate. In re Estate of Murdock, 213 Kan. 837, 850, 854, 519 P.2d 108.
10. Allowance of attorney fees approved; payable from trust income; action to construe testamentary trust provisions of will. In re Estate of Hannah, 215 Kan. 892, 900, 529 P.2d 154.
11. Attorney fees not chargeable against estate of decedent where action to enforce contract as claim against estate. Reznik v. McKee, Trustee, 216 Kan. 659, 681, 534 P.2d 243.
12. Attorney fees allowed as costs of litigation; action settled roles of trustee and beneficiaries. Jennings v. Murdock, 220 Kan. 182, 183, 215, 553 P.2d 846.
13. Allowance of attorney fees directed; services were beneficial and necessary for proper consideration of will. In re Estate of Mellott, 1 Kan. App. 2d 709, 721, 574 P.2d 960.
14. Unsuccessful contest of will not part of proceeding to probate prior will; duty to produce prior will under K.S.A. 59-618 not justification for payment of expenses of contest. In re Estate of Carothers, 3 Kan. App. 2d 156, 158, 591 P.2d 1091.
15. The term "successfully opposes" construed as ultimate resolution of issue; requirement applied to attorney fees and expenses. In re Estate of Robinson, 232 Kan. 752, 754, 659 P.2d 172 (1983).
16. Cited in holding compromise and settlement generally bars preexisting claims tied to settled estate and will dispute. In re Estate of Engels, 10 Kan. App. 2d 103, 107, 692 P.2d 400 (1984).
17. No intention that fee based on contingency dependent on success; court need only establish employment, not terms thereof. In re Estate of Robinson, 236 Kan. 431, 439, 690 P.2d 1383 (1984).
18. Attorney fees allowed where contesting final settlement in good faith and for cause increased estate by $278,000. In re Estate of Jud, 238 Kan. 268, 278, 279, 710 P.2d 1241 (1985).
19. Facts sufficient to justify allowance of attorney fees to heir at law or beneficiary examined. In re Trusteeship of the Will of Daniels, 247 Kan. 349, 357, 799 P.2d 499 (1990).
20. Award of attorney fees to appellants where Supreme Court reversed trial court decision noted. In re Estate of Raney, 247 Kan. 359, 376, 799 P.2d 986 (1990).
21. Attorney fees not awarded because petitioner's claim was not successful. In re Estate of Mildrexter, 25 Kan. App. 2d 834, 971 P.2d 758 (1999).
22. As will contest was not successful, party contesting will was not entitled to attorney fees. In re Estate of Haneberg, 270 Kan. 365, 14 P.3d 1088 (2000).
23. Absent express statutory authority court cannot order payment of attorney fees from decedent's estate. In re Estate of Gardiner, 29 Kan. App. 2d 158, 23 P.3d 902 (2001).
24. In an award of attorney fees to a party who successfully opposes probate of a will, a party's bad faith is irrelevant, only determination should be reasonableness of the amount requested. In re Estate of Strader, 301 Kan. 50, 61, 339 P.3d 769 (2014).
LEGISLATIVE COORDINATING COUNCIL
12/17/2024
Meeting Notice
12/02/2024 Meeting Notice Agenda 11/14/2024 Meeting Notice Agenda 10/23/2024 Meeting Notice Agenda 09/09/2024 Meeting Notice Agenda 08/21/2024 Meeting Notice Agenda LCC Policies REVISOR OF STATUTES
Chapter 72 Statute Transfer List
Kansas School Equity & Enhancement Act Gannon v. State A Summary of Special Sessions in Kansas Bill Brief for Senate Bill No. 1 Bill Brief for House Bill No. 2001 2024 New, Amended & Repealed Statutes By Bill 2024 New, Amended & Repealed Statutes By KSA 2023 New, Amended & Repealed Statutes By Bill 2023 New, Amended & Repealed Statutes By KSA USEFUL LINKS
Session Laws
OTHER LEGISLATIVE SITES
Kansas LegislatureAdministrative Services Division of Post Audit Research Department |